Topic Battle

Where Everything Fights Everything

Hedgehog

Hedgehog

Spiny nocturnal insectivore that rolls into defensive balls and has become an unlikely video game icon.
VS
Mars

Mars

Red planet and humanity's next frontier.

The Matchup

In what the Cambridge Journal of Improbable Comparisons has called 'the most audacious cross-categorical analysis since the infamous Teaspoon versus Democracy study of 1987,' we present a comprehensive examination of Erinaceus europaeus against the fourth planet from the Sun. The hedgehog, weighing approximately 1.2 kilograms and capable of curling into a defensive sphere, faces Mars, weighing approximately 6.39 x 10^23 kilograms and notably incapable of curling into anything. Yet size, as the Royal Institute of Dimensional Irrelevance reminds us, is merely one variable among many.

Battle Analysis

Cultural impact Mars Wins
30%
70%
Hedgehog Mars

Hedgehog

The hedgehog has achieved remarkable cultural penetration, most notably through Sonic the Hedgehog, a blue anthropomorphic version that has generated over $13 billion in franchise revenue. Mrs Tiggy-Winkle, Beatrix Potter's washerwoman hedgehog, introduced the species to literary consciousness in 1905. The Oxford Centre for Fictional Animal Economics estimates hedgehogs appear in 340% more children's books than their ecological significance would suggest. In British gardens, they have achieved near-sacred status, with the Hedgehog Preservation Society boasting 47,000 members.

Mars

Mars has dominated human imagination for millennia, from the Roman god of war to H.G. Wells' invading tripods. David Bowie enquired about its spiders. NASA has successfully landed five rovers on its surface, each generating substantial cultural discourse. The Journal of Planetary Celebrity notes that Mars appears in over 600 feature films, compared to hedgehogs' mere 23. Elon Musk has predicated his entire personal brand upon its eventual colonisation. The Manchester Institute of Celestial Fame ranks Mars as 'the most famous planet after Earth, obviously.'

VERDICT

While Sonic commands genuine devotion, Mars has shaped human mythology, literature, and aerospace policy for thousands of years. Mars claims this criterion through sheer temporal accumulation.

Practical utility Hedgehog Wins
70%
30%
Hedgehog Mars

Hedgehog

Hedgehogs consume approximately 200 grams of invertebrates nightly, providing invaluable pest control services valued by the Royal Horticultural Society at approximately 47 pence per garden per night. They require minimal maintenance, self-navigate, and produce fertiliser as a byproduct. The University of Kent School of Applied Mammalogy calculates that Britain's 1.5 million hedgehogs save gardeners 36 million annually in slug pellet costs. Their aesthetic contribution to evening garden atmospherics remains, according to researchers, 'genuinely charming.'

Mars

Mars currently provides no practical utility whatsoever to any human being. It grows no vegetables. It controls no pests. It cannot be stroked. The Interplanetary Utility Assessment Centre in Rotterdam confirms that Mars has contributed 'precisely zero tangible benefits to humanity' despite billions spent on its investigation. Future utility remains speculative, with the Treasury Select Committee on Space Expenditure noting that 'useful outcomes remain several decades and approximately 500 billion away.'

VERDICT

The hedgehog delivers measurable, immediate value to British gardens tonight. Mars delivers nothing except photographs and existential contemplation. The hedgehog wins on pure pragmatic grounds.

Surface hospitality Hedgehog Wins
70%
30%
Hedgehog Mars

Hedgehog

The hedgehog's surface presents approximately 7,000 spines, each measuring 2-3 centimetres in length. While initially uninviting, the European Hedgehog Tactility Survey of 2019 found that 73% of handlers described the experience as 'surprisingly pleasant once you know the angle.' The underbelly offers a contrasting softness that researchers at the Bristol Mammalian Texture Laboratory rate as 'genuinely delightful.' Temperature regulation maintains a comfortable 35-37 degrees Celsius during active periods.

Mars

Mars presents a surface temperature averaging minus 62 degrees Celsius, with extremes reaching minus 125 degrees at the poles. The Planetary Hospitality Index compiled by the Stockholm Institute of Celestial Welcomeness rates the Martian surface as 'categorically hostile to all known forms of picnic.' The soil contains perchlorates toxic to human thyroid function, whilst dust storms can envelop the entire planet for months. The University of Glasgow's Department of Unfortunate Destinations notes that 'even the most optimistic estate agent would struggle.'

VERDICT

Despite its spiny exterior, the hedgehog offers warmth, occasional softness, and zero chance of perchlorate poisoning. The hedgehog takes this criterion decisively.

Real estate potential Mars Wins
30%
70%
Hedgehog Mars

Hedgehog

A hedgehog offers approximately 0.008 square metres of usable surface area, insufficient for any meaningful development. The Royal Institute of Chartered Surveyors (Unusual Properties Division) confirms that planning permission for structures on hedgehog surfaces has never been granted. Furthermore, hedgehogs move unpredictably and hibernate for four months annually, making them 'fundamentally unsuitable for fixed infrastructure,' according to the Leeds Building Society's experimental lending criteria.

Mars

Mars presents 144.8 million square kilometres of potential development land, equivalent to Earth's entire land surface area. The Interplanetary Property Consortium has already begun preliminary zoning discussions. Olympus Mons alone, at 22 kilometres high, offers what the Dubai School of Ambitious Architecture calls 'unprecedented penthouse opportunities.' While current prices remain theoretical, the Galactic Land Registry anticipates Mars will represent 'the most significant real estate opportunity since the Louisiana Purchase.'

VERDICT

With 144.8 million square kilometres versus 0.008 square metres, this criterion requires no further commentary. Mars achieves total dominance in spatial availability.

Defensive capabilities Hedgehog Wins
70%
30%
Hedgehog Mars

Hedgehog

When threatened, the hedgehog employs the orbicularis muscle to contract into a near-impenetrable sphere within 0.3 seconds. This defensive posture has proven effective against foxes, badgers, and curious dogs for approximately 15 million years. The Edinburgh School of Mammalian Fortification rates the hedgehog's defensive strategy as 'elegantly simple and remarkably successful.' The spines themselves can support weights up to 200 times the hedgehog's body mass without significant deformation.

Mars

Mars possesses no defensive capabilities whatsoever. It cannot curl into a ball. It lacks spines. When NASA sent rovers, Mars simply accepted them without resistance. The Planetary Defence Assessment Board in Geneva notes that Mars has been bombarded by asteroids for 4.5 billion years without developing any countermeasures. Its thin atmosphere, only 1% of Earth's density, offers negligible protection against cosmic radiation or incoming spacecraft. The Journal of Celestial Vulnerability describes Mars as 'essentially defenceless.'

VERDICT

The hedgehog has spent millions of years perfecting a defensive strategy that works. Mars has spent billions of years getting hit by rocks. The hedgehog demonstrates clear superiority in self-preservation.

👑

The Winner Is

Mars

42 - 58

In this extraordinary confrontation between the compact and the cosmic, Mars emerges victorious with a score of 58 to 42. The Red Planet's dominance in cultural impact and real estate potential ultimately outweighs the hedgehog's superior defensive capabilities, surface hospitality, and practical utility. Yet this margin should give interplanetary enthusiasts pause. A creature weighing approximately 0.0000000000000000000002% of Mars' mass has proven remarkably competitive across multiple criteria. The International Bureau of Categorical Comparison notes that this represents 'the strongest performance by a mammal against a planet since the infamous Badger versus Neptune adjudication of 2014.' Mars wins, but the hedgehog has earned considerable respect from the astronomical community.

Hedgehog
42%
Mars
58%

Share this battle

More Comparisons